Monday, April 27, 2015

A LOSS OF GREAT MAGNITUDE

It is with what, in perhaps melodramatic contexts, is known as "a heavy heart", that we must report the loss of one of northeast Ohio's more architecturally significant structures.  Apparently constructed in 1898, it was built as the summer residence for John Gehring, then the President of the Gehring Brewing Company of Cleveland, Ohio.  Located in Avon Lake (Lorain County), with the rear of the property overlooking Lake Erie, Gehring commissioned Cleveland architect Frederick Baird to provide a "Swiss Chalet" design complete with an expansive porch and balcony framed by that style's visually prominent, pierced balustrades.  As was the practice in times gone by in regards to 'country' residences, Gehring called his summer home "Green Gables".
1900

1905































1911

This lakefront property has a street frontage of 200 feet and a depth of over 600 feet.  Someone with apparently more money than he knew what to do with somehow acquired the property in late-2013 -- with no intention of making any use of this spectacular house.  It was demolished sometime within the past twelve months.  A house approximately three times the size is presently [April 2015] under construction at the site.

The Swiss Chalet style had not been hugely popular and most examples were built, briefly, between 1900 and 1910.  Therefore, this was a very early example, of a generally rare architectural style. The house's exterior had been essentially unaltered, with the only obvious change being the screening-in of some sections of the porch and balcony.
 
1999
The Swiss Chalet style had not been hugely popular and most examples were built, briefly, between 1900 and 1910.  Therefore, this was a very early example, of a generally rare architectural style. The house's exterior had been essentially unaltered, with the only obvious change being the screening-in of some sections of the porch and balcony.  Reportedly, a complementing Swiss-style beach house was also built, although no image of such a building is known.  A Swiss-style coach house was definitely built.  It was positioned very close to the street.  Added across the entire 200 feet of street frontage was a wrought-iron fence, with two sets of grand gates.  Both the coach house and iron fence were still present at the time of this post, but it should be only obvious that the "modern-minded" new owner will soon eliminate them, as well.

Public records reveal that the new owner purchased this property at a price of over a million dollars.  The house presently under construction appears as if its final cost could approach yet another million dollars.  With this sort of wealth, the new owner could have easily afforded the cost to move the Gehring House, preferably to another property, where its architectural magnificence could have lived on for many more years.  But, instead, yet another grand historic building has been callously tossed aside, like yesterday's garbage.

Thursday, April 02, 2015

IGNATIUS.......A SAINT, HE AIN'T

The latest session of the "De-Landmarking Commission" of the City Of Cleveland gave their blessings to St. Ignatius High School to demolish yet another historic structure in their possession. It is a house that was built in the late-1860s for George Schlecter.  It is located in the Ohio City Local Historic District.  Owned by the school since 1991 and used by them primarily for some function related to volunteers, the school has decided that they want to expand the parking lot that they own which surrounds the house.  Removing the house will give them six parking spaces.
2900 Carroll - 2015 photo

2900 Carroll - 1957 photo

Ignatius has been in this general location since the 1880s.  They could have easily relocated to suburbia, as many a Cleveland area private school did.  Instead, mimicking the standard strategy of inner-city universities, they proceeded to acquire as many of the surrounding properties as possible.  The nearby buildings are/were strictly 19th-century.  The quantity of historic buildings that they have acquired and demolished over the decades is staggering.  After the 1960s flight to the suburbs of anyone who could afford to do so, particularly businesses and institutions, the City Of Cleveland has obliged every desire for which Ignatius has needed their cooperation, for fear that Ignatius finally will relocate outside of Cleveland if they do not.  Entire blocks of historic buildings have been demolished, the streets officially "vacated" by the City, and the land they once occupied transferred to Ignatius.  They apparently have a "cart-blanche" relationship with the City.  [Note:  Apparently as a further expression of 'solidarity' with the school, the "De-Landmarking Commission" in the same recent session also re-confirmed the approval they gave to Ignatius last year to demolish another mid-19th-century house, a block or so down the street. (See the post from December 21, 2014.)]  How much longer will it be before the City obligingly removes the ultimate obstacle to Ignatius -- the "Historic District" status of the neighborhood?